RFD-09 is a deficiency memo issued under Section 54 read with Rule 90(3) of the CGST Act/Rules when your GST refund application has missing documents, incorrect computations, or incomplete details. You have 15 days to rectify deficiencies or your application is treated as never filed. Our AI identifies every deficiency and drafts a compliant response in under 60 seconds.
GST Form RFD-09 is a deficiency memo (also called a "reply to show cause notice for refund") issued by the Proper Officer under Rule 90(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017, read with Section 54 of the CGST Act. It is issued when the Proper Officer finds that a refund application filed in Form RFD-01 is incomplete, has deficiencies in documentation, or contains computational errors.
The RFD-09 notice must be issued within 15 days of the receipt of the refund application. It specifies the exact deficiencies — missing export documents, incorrect refund computation under Rule 89(4) or 89(5), missing CA/CS certificates, incomplete Statement of Invoices, or wrong bank account details. The taxpayer gets 15 days from the date of receiving RFD-09 to file a fresh/corrected application addressing all deficiencies.
This notice is critical because under Rule 90(3), if the deficiencies are not rectified within 15 days, the original refund application is deemed to have not been filed. This means you lose the original application date — which can impact the 2-year limitation period under Section 54(1) and the right to interest on delayed refund under Section 56. A prompt, complete response is essential to preserve your refund claim.
Legal Section
Section 54, Rule 90(3) CGST
Time Limit to Respond
15 Days from Communication
Consequence of Non-Response
Application Deemed Not Filed
Risk Level
High — Loss of Refund Claim Date
Refund Processing Time
60 Days from Complete Application
Refund Types Covered
Export / Inverted Duty / Excess Balance
Missing Export Documents (BRC/FIRC/Shipping Bills)
For export refunds, Bank Realisation Certificates (BRC) or Foreign Inward Remittance Certificates (FIRC) must be attached. Missing shipping bills, bills of lading, or Let Export Orders are common deficiencies flagged in RFD-09.
Incorrect Refund Computation Under Rule 89
Wrong application of the refund formula under Rule 89(4) for zero-rated supplies or Rule 89(5) for inverted duty structure. Errors in turnover calculation, net ITC computation, or adjusted total turnover are frequently flagged.
Incomplete Statement of Invoices (Statement 3/3A)
Statement 3 (for zero-rated supplies) or Statement 3A (for inverted duty) must list all invoices with HSN codes, tax rates, and amounts. Missing invoices, incorrect HSN mapping, or mismatch with GSTR-1 data triggers RFD-09.
Missing CA/CS Certificate or Undertaking
For refund claims above Rs. 2 lakh, a CA certificate in specific format is required. Missing undertaking that ITC claimed has not been carried forward, or missing declaration for SEZ supplies, triggers this deficiency.
Mismatch Between RFD-01 and GSTR-1/GSTR-3B
The refund amount claimed in RFD-01 must reconcile with turnover and tax declared in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B for the same period. Any discrepancy in turnover figures, ITC claimed, or tax paid triggers a deficiency memo. The officer cross-references all three sources.
Verify the Notice and Note Deficiencies
Check the DIN, your GSTIN, notice date, and the refund application ARN referenced. List every deficiency mentioned in the RFD-09 — these are the exact items you must address. Note the 15-day deadline from the date of communication. Verify the refund type (export, inverted duty, excess balance) and the applicable Rule 89 sub-rule.
Gather All Missing Documents
Collect the specific documents cited as missing: BRC/FIRC from your bank, shipping bills from customs (available on ICEGATE), CA certificate in the prescribed format, undertaking/declaration letters, and any other document specified. Ensure all documents are self-attested and clearly legible.
Correct Computational Errors
If the deficiency relates to incorrect refund computation, recalculate using the correct formula. For exports without payment of tax: Refund = (Turnover of zero-rated supply / Adjusted Total Turnover) x Net ITC [Rule 89(4)]. For inverted duty: apply Rule 89(5). Prepare a revised Statement 3/3A with corrected figures and cross-reference with GSTR-1/GSTR-3B.
Reconcile with GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B
Prepare a reconciliation statement showing that the refund amount matches your return filings. Map each invoice in Statement 3/3A to the corresponding entry in GSTR-1. Ensure the ITC figure matches GSTR-3B Table 4. This reconciliation is the most critical document — officers rely on it heavily during processing.
Draft the Response Letter
Address the Proper Officer with the RFD-09 reference. For each deficiency, provide a point-wise response: the deficiency noted, the corrective action taken, and the document now being attached. Cite Section 54, Rule 89, Rule 90(3), and relevant CBIC Circulars (such as Circular 125/44/2019 on refund issues). Request expedited processing.
File the Corrected Application Within 15 Days
Login to the GST portal, navigate to the refund section, and file the corrected application against the RFD-09 reference. Upload all documents as PDF attachments. After filing, the 60-day processing clock under Section 54(7) restarts from this date. Download the acknowledgment and track status regularly.
To
The Proper Officer (CGST/SGST)
[Officer Name, Designation]
[Jurisdictional Division/Range]
Subject
Reply to Deficiency Memo in Form GST RFD-09 bearing DIN [number] dated [date] regarding Refund Application ARN [ARN] for the period [period] — GSTIN: [your GSTIN]
Reference
RFD-09 dated [date] | DIN: [DIN number] | Original RFD-01 ARN: [ARN] | Refund Type: [Export/Inverted Duty/Excess Balance]
Body
Prayer
In light of the above submissions and corrected documents, it is respectfully prayed that the deficiencies may be treated as rectified, and the refund of Rs. [amount] may kindly be sanctioned within the statutory time limit of 60 days under Section 54(7) of the CGST Act.
Deficiency Parsing
Upload your RFD-09 PDF. AI extracts every deficiency item, categorizes them (documentation, computation, reconciliation), and generates a checklist of documents you need to prepare with specific instructions for each.
Refund Computation Verifier
AI verifies your refund calculation against Rule 89(4) or 89(5) formula, cross-checks with GSTR-1/GSTR-3B data, and highlights computation errors. Generates a corrected Statement 3/3A if needed.
Response Generation
Generates a complete response letter addressing each deficiency point-wise, with correct legal citations (Section 54, Rule 89, Rule 90, relevant Circulars), reconciliation tables, and a proper prayer clause for expedited processing.
Upload your refund deficiency memo. AI identifies every deficiency, verifies your refund computation, and generates a complete response with corrected documents checklist.
No credit card required. Analyse your first 3 notices free.